Each month, the training class boys take us through some hot topics of the day and puts us on the spot to come up with how we would have handled various situations. The instructors take the lead and a debate that any power-sharing nation would be proud of ensues. Much to contrary belief we do come up with a consensus and we will share our thoughts with you via this page. See if you agree.

This month we talk about simulation The two clips we have chosen for www.sfar-glasgow.co.uk highlight how positioning during play a big part in decision making as a referee.

Clip 1

Simulation - Clip 1 (469k)	Simulation - Clip 1 - Reverse angle (1.45mb)

In a minute, click the images above to view the first of two clips that were discussed but before you watch it, keep this in mind - On first viewing would you have given a penalty kick?

Now watch the reverse angle clip and see how much of a difference positioning can make.

Please note that you will need Microsoft's Media Player to view the footage. You can download the latest version here.

Watch clip 1 and ask yourself was it a penalty kick?

Watch it again. This time ask yourself was there any contact?

Now watch clip 1 - reverse angle This time ask yourself is this now part of our game?

Clip 2

Simulation - Clip 2 (267k)	Simulation - Clip 2- Reverse angle (1mb)

Watch clip 2 and ask yourself was it a penalty kick?

Watch it again. This time ask yourself was there any contact?

Now watch clip 2- reverse angle This time ask yourself is this now part of our game?

Click here to find out what the Glasgow Association's view is.